Book Review Etiquette
Authors can’t sell books without reviews. Especially now that a lot of authors are going the self-published route, book reviews are crucial elements that authors seek and crave. Well, good reviews are craved.
Recently, there has been a trend for readers to post reviews before they have even read the book.
A fellow author recently received the following ONE star review: "I did not read it I just downloaded it," says Raebeth Buda, author of ‘Silenced’ and host of the Writing World web site. “Last year I also got a ONE star review that said, 'I haven't read it yet, I will leave a review when I do.' They have yet to review it. That star has been sitting there hurting my rating ever since. And with only 10 ratings on that particular site, it hurts a LOT.”
It hurts the author because most book review sites give an average star rating, figuring all the reviews into one score. It’s like getting straight A’s all semester, and then getting one F that pulls your grade average down to a C.
“It seems like common sense, but I think more people need to be aware of how much needless one star reviews can hurt. It's great you bought the book, [and] it's great you intend to review it. But leaving a one star 'placeholder' hurts the author much more than leaving no review at all,” Buda says.
Stars on a book review are pretty much equal to the five point grading system used in schools. A five star rating is the same as an A on an essay. It means you thoroughly enjoyed the book. Four stars means the book was enjoyable, but had a few faults. A three star rating means the book barely passed. Anything below three stars warns other readers to pass the book by and buy something else. A one star rating means the author should not have published the book in the first place.
When writing a review for a book, the reader should give a summary of the story to let the next reader know what the subject of the book is about. It also lets the reader know that the reviewer did in fact read the book. It should then point out the book’s virtues and weaknesses. Is it well paced? Does the plot make sense? Are the clues foreshadowed, or does the answer appear out of nowhere? Are the characters believable and likeable? Is it well researched?
The conclusion of the review then gives an overall reaction to the book: it was a pleasant read, it was a page turner, I couldn’t put it down, I highly recommend the book, I can’t wait for the next one. The conclusion of the review should not be what is called a 'spoiler': the butler did it. It’s acceptable to say that the ending was surprising, but not to say what the surprise actually was.
So, please, write your reviews, but follow the rules and format of a good review. Even if your opinion is bad, every review posted should be good in quality, helpful to other readers, and a true reflection of the reader’s opinions.
Guest Blogger Bio
Paula Hrbacek is the author of five books, including Stars Shine After Dark, a sweet Christian romance, available in paperback, Kindle and Nook.
Day Camp in Hawaii, a complete program guide for summer camp or summer school, is available in paperback, Nook and Kindle. For more information see http://paulahrbacek.weebly.com or her author page at https://www.amazon.com/author/paulahrbacek.
She also writes two columns for The Examiner, a free online newspaper; Children’s Arts and Crafts, and Book Reviews.
Universal Amazon link: mybook.to/DayCampHawaii
Also in paperback at B&N.
Check out our latest Writing in the Modern Age blog article here.
My guest today is T.J. Banks. Hello, T.J.! Welcome to Writing in the Modern Age! It’s such a pleasure to have you.
Can you tell us a little bit about your latest book? When did it come out? Where can we get it?
My latest book, Sketch People: Stories Along the Way (Inspiring Voices/Guideposts 2012), is a series of interviews or "conversations" with people about what they do and why it matters to them. There are a few exceptions to this particular "rule": "The Message," for instance, is included simply because it's a powerful story about bonds that transcend death. But most of the stories are about people pursuing their callings. There's this saying -- "Follow your heart, and everything else will fall into place." Well, I'd say that my interviewees are doing just that and then some. They're doing things they feel called upon to do, regardless of whether everything else has fallen into place. Actors, writers, activists -- they're all doing work they believe in.
Sketch People can be purchased directly from me, bookstore.inspiringvoices.com, amazon.com, and barnesandnoble.com.
Is there anything that prompted your latest book? Something that inspired you?
I had just finished working on A Time for Shadows, a World War I novel that had taken me six-and-a-half years to write. I needed to switch gears and work on something completely different. I found myself turning back to journalism...which was, after all, where I'd started out as a writer. I'd always loved interviewing people and finding out what made them tick. So, I thought, why not do a blog that allowed me to do just that? That was the beginning of my "Sketch People" blog, which eventually turned into the book of the same name.
Great! So, when did you know you wanted to write? Or has it always been a pastime of yours?
Since I was eight-years-old. I'm not exactly sure how it came about, only that one day, I went from reading stories to writing them, complete with illustrations. By the time I was nine, I was making off with the tan copy books we practiced our penmanship in. My best friend and I used them for all our stories and poems. We'd grab a stuffed animal or a model horse from the shelf and just commence writing about it. And when we weren't able to get together, one of us would call the other, and we'd make up stories over the phone.
Do you have any favorite authors?
I'm very partial to British novelist Elizabeth Goudge (1900 - 1984): her books are both spiritual and grounded, and I find myself turning to her work when I'm at loose ends. Other favorites include Joyce Stranger, who wrote such vivid stories of people and their animals in the British and Welsh countryside, and Deric Longden. I love Longden's quirky sense of humor. And I like getting lost in a good historical novel, so Margaret Campbell Barnes and Janet Holt Giles are also on my list.
Do you write in a specific place? Time of day?
There's a little room off our kitchen that I use as a study, and, yes, I do a lot of my writing there. But years ago, I learned to write just about anywhere -- sitting on the steps, waiting for the commuter bus; under the dryer at the hairdresser's; and at this Italian bakery while my son was at religious school. As long as I have my portfolio and pen -- I like to write out my rough drafts in long-hand -- I'm good.
I prefer to get started on my writing as soon as I come in from my morning run. It doesn't always work out that way, of course. But that doesn't stop me from trying.
Are there any words you'd like to impart to fellow writers. Any advice?
Write what engages you. Now, I know that sometimes -- a lot of times -- we're locked into the dishwater-dull writing assignments or projects. But whenever possible, we need to write about what matters to us. There's this Edith Wharton character who talks about artists needing to feed their work with their own entrails. Well, that's about the size of it. If you write something that you don't care about, your readers will know -- they're not stupid -- and if you don't care about it, why should they?
But I'm not talking just about the readers here. A novel...a screenplay...a collection of poetry...all these things require a tremendous amount of work if you're going to do them right. Why would you expend that much time and energy on something you didn't love?
Here is the blurb for Sketch People: Stories Along the Way.
We all have stories to tell. Sketch People is a collection of stories about people—their work, their passions, and their experiences. In this compilation by T. J. Banks, a woman tells the story of a message she received from an old family friend following the death of her late mother’s dog. Another woman, a cancer survivor, recounts her long and complex journey from geologist to master gardener to environmental and safety engineer to goat’s-milk soap maker. An actor and playwright talks about the inner workings of his craft, while actress Tippi Hedren reflects not on her film career but on her work with the wild cats of the Shambala refuge in Acton, California. The collection also includes an affectionate tribute to the late writer and activist Cleveland Amory, who more than lived up to his personal philosophy of “simply to be kind.” Each sketch brings us a little closer to understanding how these particular folks got where they were going and what transformed them along the way— each person has a spark, a tale worth telling.
Here is an excerpt from Sketch People: Stories Along the Way.
She likes to start on the eyes as soon as possible in her portraits, artist Sally Logue explains. “It’s important to get them right. I usually start with a rough outline of the head and then work from the eyes outwards. You’d be taught to work from top left to bottom, gradually building up color and tone, but I like the eyes to bring the portrait to life early on.” They really are “the windows to the soul,” she says, and they speak to her.
They speak to the viewer, too. The animals and birds in Logue’s portraits draw us in with their eyes. A wistful Blue-cream Point Siamese…an elfin Ruddy Abyssinian…an inquisitive Springer Spaniel…two British Giant rabbits looking like they’re chatting companionably over a lettuce lunch…all of them are vivid presences, seemingly ready to step off the pastel paper and become fully dimensional. Logue has a strong rapport with her subjects, and it shows in every pastel-penciled line. The word that keeps coming up in her customers’ comments is “captured,” and they’re not always talking about a physical likeness. More often than not, their remarks have to do with intangibles: “you captured their spirit,” “ you've managed to capture so much about them…it really does look as if you know Simon and Barney well,” or “her character is captured totally.” Some folks even admit to crying upon receiving a portrait of a deceased pet. “I don’t feel like I’m looking at a portrait and it really brings it home that he is no longer with us,” one customer wrote.
-- From "Soul-Catcher: Sally Logue," Sketch People: Stories Along the Way
Talking with actor and writer Jay Amari is a whole lot like looking down a kaleidoscope. A turn of the tube or the conversation and the configurations of color and light tumble apart, shift, and re-form themselves. Twirl it again, and yet another pattern emerges.
What does remain clear and constant, however, is Amari’s intense level of creative energy. He is the author of Crosstown Traffic, a collection of plays: two of them – “Cloudy All Day” and “The Greatest” – were finalists in the Actors Theatre of Louisville National Ten-Minute Play Series in 1992 and 1993. He has taught writing workshops at Columbia University. He has acted in film and on T.V., his most recent work being in “Manalive,” a film based on the 1912 G. K. Chesterton novel. And he’s working on several screenplays plus a story, which has been appearing in installments on Facebook.
So, a Renaissance man? Amari laughs. "I guess I am because I'm working on a self-produced film, shot on video, which is probably going to be different from any other kind of movie that anybody else has made." That movie, "My Day," basically covers "parts of a day, only it's going to be four seasons, so there'll be summer, winter, spring, and fall. The film itself is going to be interspersed with archival footage from other films, which will add commentary to my daily activities." He'll also be weaving in a number of one-minute segments in which people tell him in a single sentence what their days are like. He has, he adds, scripted about 40 pages of it, "but now what I'm finding is, just the process of shooting is showing me all this other stuff that is available. [So it] has sort of become this process-oriented film. But I'm going to be very happy with it when I finally get it finished because you're gonna see a lot of growth in it. Documentary-like, but it's still a fiction film."
-- From "A One-Man Show: Jay Amari," Sketch People: Stories Along the Way
Universal Reader Link: https://books2read.com/u/4Nxwj9
T. J. Banks is the author of Sketch People: Stories Along the Way, A Time for Shadows, Catsong, Derv & Co.: A Life Among Felines, Souleiado, and Houdini, a cat novel which the late writer and activist Cleveland Amory enthusiastically branded “a winner.” Catsong, a collection of her best cat stories, was the winner of the 2007 Merial Human-Animal Bond Award. A Contributing Editor to laJoie, she has received writing awards from the Cat Writers’ Association (CWA, ByLine, and The Writing Self. Her work has appeared in numerous anthologies, including Guideposts’ Soul Menders, Their Mysterious Ways, Miracles of Healing, and Comfort From Beyond. She has also worked as a stringer for the Associated Press and as an instructor for the Writer’s Digest School.
Amazon Author Central: http://www.amazon.com/T.-J.-Banks/e/B001KHC62M/ref=sr_ntt_srch_lnk_1?qid=1369025849&sr=1-1
Check out our latest Writing in the Modern Age blog article here.
Visit our old posts on Blogger instead.
A glance at Marie's books
Cool new feature!
The fact is…our policy has changed considerably, at least for a while. Check out our 'Blog Policy' for more information about the types of features offered, how you can purchase a guest spot, my policy on review requests, and rules for guest writers. Starting from 2021, I was charging for some types of posts. Of course, there is never a fee for a guest article, as long as you adhere to the blog's theme. I also will not charge for big multi-author events which I host (these are giveaways or participation questions, and it's obvious what materials you're providing). If you'd like to submit a guest book review (no, I don't write book reviews, please don't ask me), I will always accept those and not charge you a fee at all. Starting in 2022, I WILL NO LONGER BE posting new release features, cover reveals, Author's Bookshelf features, author interviews, character interviews, and poetry spotlights. I am far too overwhelmed with other work to do constant blog posts. I'll still be writing my own articles sometimes and hosting multi-author special features. For companies that can afford a sponsored post, I'm willing to discuss a reasonable quote for a specialized article which fits within the blog's theme (No blatant promotions). Email me at
if you wish to participate in a unique post. Feel free to approach me with your creative ideas about a blog post. Slots at Writing in the Modern Age are always first come, first served. Contact us and reserve a spot! Refer to the 'guest schedule' at the top of the screen for further clarification about availability. Thanks for understanding.
Thoughts and opinions by guest authors do not necessarily represent any thoughts and opinions by this website's administrator, nor are they directly endorsed. All writings on the blog are subject to review and editing. Please visit our blog policy to understand the site's theme a little better.
Use our hashtag #WritModAge when you mention us!
Should you edit your own work? Definitely! - The Ultimate Guide to Editing a Book
Are you a technical writer? Look no further for some tools of the trade!
Love physical books like me? Check out this cool DIY link!
Sign up for Marie's author newsletter! Get on her mailing list @